Tuesday 22 May 2012

Detroit, Ruin Porn and what's missing

ABANDONED HOMES. That is what you the reader expect when you hear and see images of Detroit, right? The media perhaps uses those former homes to metaphorically suggest the perception of Detroit being a shell of a city, empty, lost and unloved, or as some websites state a post-apocalyptic wasteland. A camera will snap images of neglected homes, buildings, schools and streets. So why would you think that Detroit wasn't like that? 

At times the media seem hellbent on showcasing Detroit in a negative light - the newspapers you'll read will highlight endlessly blight and poverty. Photographers come and snap hundreds of images of abandoned burnt out buildings living up to the Ruin Porn craze. The media talks and photographs the Central Michigan Railway as if it is some tomb to abandonment that Detroit stands for. They snap, they write and then they leave. But their images and words recreate, continue and uphold the horrors and poverty that apparently dwells in Detroit - they write and post what people now assume Detroit to be. So why would readers like you assume Detroit to be any different when the media comes to the city and tells you what it's really like?


       Google Detroit and or Ruin Porn you'll get images like this. [Click each image for original source]

Well some people do come to Detroit - those intent on experiencing this Ruin Porn craze - but what actually is it? Its those who come to the city merely to be voyeurs on "devastation tours", to document the presumed devastation within the urban vista - to visually stimulate the sense of destruction and withdrawal. Normally they target the aforementioned Central Michigan Railway Station alongside the Fisher and Packard Plants.  Often the beauty of these places - the light steaming through semi broken windows for instance alongside their photographic skill actually turn these places into being beautiful which encourages more people to come and try it for themselves. An endless cycle. Moreover, through Ruin Porn Chayka states Detroit has become the visual symbol for us to "be reminded that it could all fail" but that it is perhaps beyond help. For them it's time to document Detroit before it falls completely. 

Yes Detroit has abandoned fired out homes, yes it has lots of vacant plots and houses I'm not going to lie. But there is much more to the urban landscape those audiences outside are ever provided as evidence. Now here is were my interests enter - I love images and I love trying to analyse them and it's what I did for my Masters. When it comes to analyzing images what has always interested me is what is missing from the photographic frame. Because what is missing is just as important, if not more so then what is being featured within any given still.

Let us sit back for a second and reflect before we get in deep. Detroit hasn't always been documented negatively. In it's era it's been the Motor City and Motown - famed for it's car industry and music but the recession hit it hard, very hard. We all know what a certain Republican now trying to run for the White House said about "Let Detroit go Bankrupt" [Although he actually forgets saying that]. We've all see store prices in increasing and redundancies yet bankers and leaders keep their hands in pocketfuls of cash. Unfortunately Detroit became the visual metaphor for the global economic decline - Detroit lets people see what the recession has done. But to the point were they tend to forget that neglected poverty stricken parts effects many cities, American and non America alike.You don't want to imagine it happening in your own backyard, and you don't have to - that's what Detroit is for, right?

Time to think about the images;

Fullscreen capture 5222012 10546 PM.bmp

The first image is what would normally be published within an article about Detroit - it's stereotypical in it's style. The home is abandoned, the wood is falling off the front, the overarching trees case it in shadow. It's forlorn, unkempt and mangled. It even appears to have suffered in a fire with no narrative we're left to wonder if the fire was accidental or arson.

Fullscreen capture 5222012 10446 PM.bmp

 
Yet this second image comes to show what the photographers and or editors are cropping out of their images - this is what is missing. What is missing is the truth that beside this former burnt out home is a new construction perhaps by the same owner - it's new, it's clean, light and it looks welcoming. But that isn't what people expect to see so it never gets shown. It's all too easy to document what people assume, what they already perceive.

There is no real conclusion to this post. Only to state that it's too easy to merely take a photograph at face value. What's missing, what they don't want you to see is just, if not even more important then then what's being shown. Don't come to believe there is nothing in Detroit, that is all rack and ruins because its not. But if people keep believing the city to be that way - then it's never going to be able to be given the chance for a new state. A city shouldn't be allowed to fail and Ruin Porn can't be allowed to devastate Detroit even more.

You can read more about Ruin Porn and the references for this piece on these links; Motown or Ghost Town?, Ruin Lust (Guardian article about the history behind Ruin Porn), Civic Branding; Defining Detroit through the Media

I know this post might not necessarily appeal to my normal readers but I felt I needed to write this post for both myself and for Detroit. I did my MA in semiology [study of images] because I wanted to make a difference and it's something I love. I've been disheartened in my degrees lately because they have never seemed to get me anywhere and I can never seem to find that job that's out there for me. I wanted to prove to myself I still had it in me. So if you read this to the very end, thank you.

13 comments:

  1. That made for fascinating reading. It's the same here, the media are always trying to portray our urban landscape as a boarded-up, derelict wilderness when you've only got to look at the building above the derelict shop or the next street to find a thing of beauty. I certainly wouldn't be put off visiting Detroit, the images you regularly post about make it look a fascinating and grand place. x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your comment Vix, really appreciate it. I think the same can be said about Hull - the images seem to dominate peoples perceptions. I've always hoped that my posts about what we get up in and around Detroit comes to alter people's perceptions even if only for a short while.

      Delete
  2. Really interesting read. Semiology sounds like a very interesting subject. It's a shame how the media don't always portray places correctly. They have so much power, yet don't always use it in the right ways. If they carry on painting Detroit as a rundown place then it's always going to be seen that way, people need to see the reality otherwise nothing will change.

    Charlotte xo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah semiology is one of those somewhat unknown research methods but I feel in love with it. It gives you great freedom but it really does make you aware of all the tricks and ways of the media!

      Delete
  3. Semiology sounds fascinating. I know how others view Detroit and it is discouraging. I've visited on more than one occasion and saw a normal city. Seeing beyond just what the media portrays is so important.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So true! Detroit has so much more to often than people give it credit for. Plus if they continue seeing and believing in that fallen kind of image that's going to carry on hindering any attempts of bettering itself.

      Delete
  4. Those pictures are a bit heartbreaking, looks like they were stunning at one point xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Its heartbreaking seeing some of the homes - makes me want to make them all better! There's some huge mansions downtown that really could do with some love before it's too late.

      Delete
  5. I get what you mean about the media portraying Detroit in a negative light. Even in Australia the impression you get of Detroit isn't a pleasant one. Watching hardcore pawn isn't much help either ;) xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh Lordy I didn't know you got Hardcore Porn out there?! I seriously can't watch that show because that lead guy is so creepy! Honestly not everyone's like that - really are some nutters on that program.

      Delete
  6. Such a thought provoking post, I think there is a lot to be said about perception and these images certainly prove that behind ruin, there is beauty. It's so easy to dismiss a place as dire and unworthy of a visit, but I don't think you truly get to know a place unless you have visited it for yourself and seen it through your own eyes xxx

    ReplyDelete
  7. that's sensationalized journalism. it's in any country or state.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hiya Rachael,

    Urban exploration has led me to a love of Ruin Porn, my folks are from Sheffield and when visiting in the 70's & 80's I'd see a little bit more of Brightside and Meadowhall town down into piles of bricks. Salt & Pepper, and Blackburn Meadows power stations innards was the highlight of the journey up the M1 and many shots of Detroit remind me of this.

    ReplyDelete