Friday 12 April 2013

Immigration ... moving "guilt"

Source
A couple of months ago I looked into something that's been termed "immigration guilt" - that feeling that sometimes overcomes you when you reflect on moving countries and you consider and remember all that you left behind. While in my instance it can be related to moving countries, but it can just as likely be in relation to moving within the same country, moving to a new town to a new place maybe for a new job or to start at university, anywhere to start anew. 

Books, articles and websites on the subject wrap immigration guilt up with self identity, self representation of the old and new, the turmoil of relocating, questions of how does one cope with your idea of "self" in your new setting. In actuality I've experienced and internalize this sense of guilt into questioning how people in your former life and location cope, particularly parents without you, others have described questioning if migrating was the right thing to do. Its like homesickness, but much more self questioning. For me it's not that I regret, nor do I question my motive or decision to leave the UK - it was the right thing for me, for my relationship and where I am in my life. But, I left at a time where my friends are growing up and i'm not there.

Maybe it's partly selfish - I've just thought that as I sit here typing this out but with us now looking for our first house, America increasingly feels like home, and the UK not so much, my ties are slowly being cut from the homeland and sometimes it hurts - but it's natural and it's okay for it to hurt. Friends from school and university are now, like myself in our late twenties, a few are getting married, even more are having babies. One of my closest friends who I've managed to keep a friendship going with since moving is getting married in May, and while i'd love to be there, money doesn't allow. Another has been married and had a baby in the time I've being living in America. It's not that I'm jealous of them, but you can sometimes get wrapped up in this sense of guilt because you want to be there, but you can't. It can reach the point whereby you over idealize people, places and events through the "if only". Social media can make this worse and while it helps that you can keep in touch easier with people, flashes of their life on your timeline, their going out, going to weddings, showing their babies makes you feel even more remote, you're just watching their life from afar. But you have to handle the emotions and move on, other people's lives won't stop because you moved. Harsh but true and in fact they might be thinking the same about your own life and experiences as you share countless photographs of all the new places you visit, foods you try to new people you meet that they don't know. They might be hurting just as much as you because they can't be sharing those new experiences with you. 

Source
Overall it is something natural to feel, emotions are emotions, it would be worse to hide them, to ignore them and bottle them up. It's ok to move be if fifty, five hundred or five thousand miles, have moments of homesickness, feel bad about not being able to share in life's journey, to reflect but most importantly to carry on living your own life. Relocating is hard, it's a period of reflection, self evaluating and change but also new possibilities and a battle between your old self and the new - it takes a while for the two self's to settle and have a part of yourself in another place - that's part of the fun of relocating.

"I am two, one looks back
the other turns to the sea" 
Gabriel Mistral 

10 comments:

  1. I never heard of this before...wow. A friend of mine recently moved to a new state and she is feeling such severe identity loss and she couldn't describe it. This is it. Wow.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah I never thought anything described it, or if it was anything that anyone other then myself was or had experienced. It's an interesting concept and certainly rings too, it's funny how much it makes you realise how much your identity is tied to the places and people around us.

      Delete
  2. Such a well written post - you've always struck me as an incredibly determined and brave person. It can't have been easy for you, and I know leaving people behind can seem like a goodbye, but we are lucky that in this day and age we have fast technology, and we are able to at least stay in touch with loved ones this way.

    Everything always happens for a reason, a path, a destiny and you followed yours - I know I'm incredibly inspired xxx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow thank you Alice - that means a lot. I'm not great at writing about expat experiences - there's other blogs out there that do that kind of thing far more eloquently then myself but I've never seen this topic raised or written about (or at least not very often).

      I know moving countries is a huge deal for those moving and those left behind and while I know the majority of people won't be migrating in their life time, we all experience moving to new places. Hopefully this blog post might glad some people's attention - both for those who have moved or have had friends and family move away so they understand that feeling and emotion of guilt is natural and in fact just all a part of moving, that it's okay to say your homesick or you get down about being away from "home".

      Delete
  3. Really interesting post, I can imagine how this can be the case. Hope you're ok :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, i'm good just some days you have those down days and your mind gets thinking, probably because I was looking at things from my university years and got all reflective!

      Delete
  4. What an interesting and enlightening blog post. I have a couple of very close friends eho have emmigrated and I always think about how exciting their new lives are with never a passing thought for whether they feel that they are missing out on my life. A good perspective on the situation, I think. Xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Louise, it's certainly a two way situation which doesn't for some reason or another get talked about or mentioned a lot on expat or immigration blogs or forums, maybe it's because it's that other side of the coin that people don't want to think about the negative, or possible negative aspects to immigrating when it's hard enough as it is. But I think it's important to make people - both sides of the migration situation aware and know about feelings, moods and so on and how it's all part of the course. Even though we might be making this new life for ourselves we want to stay in touch and be a part of our friends life wherever they may be.

      Delete
  5. I only moved 40 minutes away in the same state and have been trying to cope, there has been a lot of other factors contributing, but moving and starting out somewhere new to you is tough. I can only imagine being an ocean + away from loved ones. I am glad you seem to be taking it well though and looking at it all in a positive light :]

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'll know what this is like soon enough. I know my family and friends will be sad when I leave (though I hope they don't feel entirely abandoned), but I'll be just as sad knowing I'll miss out on important parts of their lives. Really interesting and helpful perspective. Glad to have found your blog. (I'm currently enviously of your recent vinyl finds!)

    ReplyDelete